Healthcare Arbitration and ADR: Which Disputes Actually Belong There?
Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) encompasses many alternatives to litigation. Provisions which require ADR or arbitration have become standard language in MSO agreements, shareholder agreements, and many other legal contracts. The thing is, not every situation is a good fit for mediation or arbitration. The nature of the dispute, which laws are impacted, and many other factors determine how best to resolve a dispute. An experienced lawyer can help you decide the best way to resolve the particular problem you face.
The attorneys at Daniels, Porco & Lusardi, LLP are highly experienced New York healthcare law attorneys. Our team utilizes arbitration and ADR when appropriate or required, but are equally prepared for litigation when necessary. Let us help you pick the wisest path.
Why ADR Matters in New York Healthcare
New York’s corporate practice of medicine (CPOM) rules, professional‑entity requirements, and payer‑driven oversight make public litigation risky. Court filings will often expose sensitive:
- Compensation structures
- Management-fee arrangements
- Clinical protocols
- Compliance issues
Arbitration or mediation provide an alternative. It increases the privacy and speed of the problem-solving process. It also gives specific advantages to MSOs, private equity groups, and physician groups.
But ADR is not a universal solution. Some disputes cannot be arbitrated at all. Others lose strategic value when removed from the court system.
Disputes That Belong in Arbitration or Mediation
1. Contract Disputes Between MSOs and Professional Entities
These are the classic candidates for ADR. Management‑services agreements (MSAs), revenue‑cycle contracts, technology agreements, and performance‑based compensation structures often include arbitration clauses. ADR keeps sensitive financial arrangements private and allows parties to select arbitrators with healthcare‑specific expertise.
2. Physician‑Owner and Shareholder Conflicts
Governance disputes within a particular company are often well-suited for ADR. These disputes might be over:
- Profit distribution
- Buy-outs
- Restrictive covenants
- Voting rights
- Termination decisions
Often, a regulatory review prior to entering the agreement may help avoid these issues before they occur.
3. Vendor and Technology‑Partner Disputes
When you work with vendors or technology partners, they often include ADR provisions in their contracts. Disputes often occur over:
- Performance under the contract
- Data-handling obligations
- Payment terms
4. Employment‑Related Disputes for Non‑Union Healthcare Staff
Employers in the healthcare sector often use arbitration to handle disputes with non-clinical staff, its administrative personnel, and others. These claims often focus around:
- Compensation
- Contract interpretation
- Termination decisions
5. High‑Value Commercial Disputes Where Confidentiality Is Critical
Platforms backed by private equity or large physician groups use arbitration provisions to avoid litigation. Disputes in this area often center around:
- Valuation
- Earn-outs
- Integration obligations
- Post-transaction performance
Disputes That Do Not Belong in ADR
1. Licensure, Professional Misconduct, and Regulatory Complaints
If the dispute involves certain offices, arbitration is not appropriate. This could include proceedings before:
- New York Office of Professional Medical Conduct (OPMC)
- Department of Health (DOH)
- Medicaid
- Federal regulators
2. Insurance Coverage and Payer‑Reimbursement Disputes
Payer-reimbursement disputes or insurance coverage disputes may have to proceed through litigation or regulatory channels. Some payer contracts do include ADR provisions, however.
3. Disputes Involving Public‑Policy Questions
New York courts won’t enforce arbitration clauses if they attempt to remove issues that properly belong to the judicial system, such as:
- Public policy issues
- Patient safety concerns
- Statutory compliance issues
- CPOM violations
- Unlawful fee-splitting
- Improper clinical control
4. Claims Involving Patients or Clinical Malpractice
Medical malpractice claims can’t be forced into arbitration. Patient-care disputes belong to the court, unless both parties voluntarily agree to ADR.
5. Matters Requiring Injunctive Relief
If a party needs immediate court intervention, such as stopping a departing physician from accessing patient records or preventing an MSO from interfering with clinical decision‑making, litigation is the proper venue. Arbitration cannot provide fast, enforceable injunctive relief in the same way.

Speak to a Healthcare Attorney About Healthcare Arbitration and ADR
ADR can be an extremely powerful tool when it is the right fit. However, it is not a universal fixer of every issue. Knowing how to proceed, when it is required, and other critical details require the eye of an attorney for the best possible outcome.
The attorneys at Daniels, Porco & Lusardi, LLP are ready to help. Contact us today for a consultation.

