How to Handle Breach of Contract Claims for Medical Practices in New York
Breach of contract claims are one of the most common types of litigation in the healthcare sector. Whether it’s an employment agreement with a physician, or a supply agreement with a vendor, you need to enjoy the benefit of your bargain. If another party fails to follow through, or they accuse you of failing in some way, an attorney is critical to protecting your legal rights.
The attorneys at Daniels, Porco & Lusardi, LLP are highly experienced medical transaction attorneys who are well-versed in NY breach of contract claims. Our healthcare sector-focused attorneys bring unique insights into fighting back against violations of your rights.
1. Understand the Nature of the Alleged Breach
You first need to know what is alleged. Breach of contract claims usually fall into one of three categories:
- Material Breach: A significant failure that undermines the purpose of the agreement
- Minor Breach: A smaller deviation that may still require remedy
- Anticipatory Breach: One party signals it will not fulfill its obligations
Medical practices often face claims involving:
- Failure to meet productivity or scheduling requirements
- Disputes over compensation formulas or bonus structures
- Termination clauses and notice requirements
- MSO performance obligations
- Billing, coding, or revenue‑cycle responsibilities
- Equipment leases or service contracts
- Non‑compete or non‑solicitation provisions
2. Review the Contract Carefully
Reviewing your contract thoroughly is absolutely essential. Practices should examine:
- Exact language of the disputed provision
- Definitions, especially around terms like “cause,” “material breach,” or “performance standards”
- Notice and cure requirements, as many contracts require written notice and allow time to fix the issue
- Termination rights
- Dispute resolution clauses (mediation, arbitration, litigation)
- Governing law and venue
For MSO agreements, pay special attention to:
- Scope of services
- Control and decision‑making authority
- Fee structures
- Compliance obligations
- Data access and confidentiality
3. Gather Documentation and Evidence
New York breach of contract disputes hinge on documentation. Medical practices should immediately collect:
- Emails, messages, and written communications
- Performance reports, schedules, or productivity data
- Billing or revenue‑cycle records
- Meeting notes or internal memos
- Copies of prior amendments or addenda
- Evidence of attempts to resolve the issue
If the contract includes compliance‑related obligations, such as HIPAA, billing accuracy, or quality‑of‑care standards, documentation demonstrating adherence is especially important.
4. Follow Notice and Cure Procedures
Many healthcare contracts require formal notice before a breach claim becomes actionable. Practices should:
- Confirm whether the complaining party provided proper written notice
- Determine whether the contract allows a cure period
- Respond within the required timeframe
- Document all corrective actions taken
If the other party failed to follow the steps they were supposed to, they may be without any recourse.
5. Evaluate Operational and Regulatory Impact
Breach claims can have many other impacts as well, not just financial.
Consider:
- Whether the dispute affects clinical operations
- Whether MSO performance issues impact billing or documentation
- Whether provider contract disputes affect scheduling or coverage
- Whether the breach allegation triggers reporting obligations (e.g., OPMC, DOH, insurers)
6. Attempt Early, Structured Resolution
Many breach claims can be resolved before escalating into litigation. Effective early‑stage strategies include:
- Formal written responses
- Negotiated amendments or clarifications
- Mediation (if required or recommended by the contract)
- Temporary operational adjustments
- Payment plans or revised fee structures
7. Prepare for Litigation or Arbitration if Necessary
If informal resolution fails, medical practices should prepare for the next step outlined in the contract:
- Arbitration: common in MSO and vendor agreements
- Litigation: common in employment, partnership, and lease disputes
- Mediation: sometimes mandatory before either party can proceed
Preparation includes organizing documentation, identifying witnesses, and assessing potential damages.
8. Strengthen Future Contracts to Reduce Risk
Every breach claim is an opportunity to improve future agreements. Practices should consider:
- Clearer performance metrics
- More precise definitions of “material breach”
- Stronger notice and cure provisions
- Detailed MSO scopes of work
- Transparent compensation formulas
- Compliance‑specific obligations
- Dispute resolution pathways tailored to healthcare operations

Facing a Breach of Contract Issue in a New York Medical Practice? We’re Here to Help
Breach of contract cases may be settled through some negotiations with a skilled attorney, or may require litigation. Knowing how to avoid litigation in the first place is key, but so is having a litigation-ready attorney who knows how to protect your rights.
The attorneys at Daniels, Porco & Lusardi, LLP are ready to help. Contact us today for a consultation.

