Abstract dark red curved lines background

What Triggers an OPMC Investigation in New York?

doctor holding stethoscope

What Triggers an OPMC Investigation in New York?

An investigation by the New York State Office of Professional Medical Conduct (OPMC) can be a stressful and frightening thing. So what might trigger on of these investigations? These investigations are never random, and are triggered by discretionary or mandatory reports or events. Knowing what these triggers are can help you maintain compliance and mitigate risk.

The attorneys at Daniels, Porco & Lusardi, LLP are highly experienced medical transaction attorneys that know the impact an OPMC investigation can have on your practice. We help medical professionals through the process, and to create systems that avoid the need for these investigations in the first place. 

1. Patient Complaints and Reports

The main reason OPMC investigations are triggered are because of a filed complaint. These often come from a patient, a family member of that patient, or some other caregiver. Complaints can range from smaller things like poor bedside manner, to much more serious misconduct. Not every complaint will result in a full investigation. However, the OPMC will review the complaint to determine whether the allegations may violate New York professional practice rules. 

Common complaint-based triggers include:

  • Allegations of misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis
  • Concerns about improper prescribing
  • Claims of unprofessional behavior
  • Allegations of harassment or discrimination
  • Reports of inadequate follow-up care 
  • Abandonment complaints
  • Allegations of performing unnecessary procedures

2. Mandatory Reporting by Hospitals and Healthcare Facilities

In New York, medical institutions are required to report certain events to OPMC. These mandatory reports will often trigger an investigation, as they usually involve more serious conduct that involves patient outcomes or safety.

Facilities must report:

  • Termination, suspension, or restriction of privileges for reasons related to professional misconduct, incompetence, or impairment
  • Resignations or voluntary withdrawals during an internal investigation
  • Significant adverse events tied to provider performance
  • Patterns of poor outcomes
  • Deviations from accepted standards of care

If a hospital is forced to take action against a provider, OPMC will nearly always open an investigation. They will look to see if the conduct warrants state-level discipline as well. 

3. Criminal Charges or Convictions

If a healthcare professional is charged with or convicted of a crime, this will likely trigger an investigation. The crime may not even be related to medical care. Certain crimes especially are considered major red flags for OPMC:

  • Driving under the influence (DUI/DWI)
  • Insurance or billing fraud
  • Drug diversion or possession
  • Assault or harassment charges

4. Substance Use Concerns or Impairment

If there is a report that a medical professional was practicing while impaired, this will trigger immediate investigative action. Intoxication may be due to alcohol, medical conditions, or controlled substances. A report might come from colleagues, patients, or even law enforcement. 

Triggers include:

  • Observed intoxication or impairment while treating patients
  • Positive drug tests
  • Evidence of drug diversion
  • Behavioral changes suggesting cognitive decline or mental health concerns

5. Insurance Company or Government Agency Alerts

Certain entities will flag unusual billing patterns and suspected fraud. This is common from insurance carriers, Medicare, and Medicaid, in addition to other government agencies. The OPMC will usually open an investigation if there is suspicion of:

  • Excessive or duplicate billing
  • Billing for services not rendered
  • Unusually high procedure volumes
  • Patterns inconsistent with accepted medical practice

6. Civil Lawsuits and Malpractice Claims

A malpractice lawsuit won’t automatically cause an OPMC investigation. Certain allegations or outcomes might, however. 

Triggers include:

  • Repeated malpractice claims within a short timeframe
  • Large settlements or judgments
  • Allegations of gross negligence 
  • Reckless behavior
  • Claims involving patient death 
  • Catastrophic injury cases

The OPMC evaluates whether the lawsuit indicates a breach of professional standards requiring disciplinary action.

7. Media Coverage or Public Complaints

If there is a high-profile incident that made the news, OPMC will likely investigate even without a formal complaint. This could be a public complaint or new story on:

  • Patient harm
  • Ethical violations
  • Criminal allegations
  • Malpractice claims
medical professional examines documents with a magnifying glass

Avoid OPMC Investigations or Handle Them Appropriately with Experienced Legal Counsel

An OPMC investigation is often something that can be avoided with proper planning. However, even excellent practices may find an investigation triggered by a complaint or report, even if it has no merit. Whatever the situation, you need experienced legal counsel at your side to protect your rights. 

The attorneys at Daniels, Porco & Lusardi, LLP are ready to help. Contact us today for a consultation.